U.S. EXPAT TAX GUIDE – INDIA
Do US citizens in India need to report investment profits to the IRS?
Yes, US citizens and Green Card holders living in India must report any capital gains from investments such as stocks, shares, and cryptocurrencies to the IRS.
Table of contents
The US tax system applies to all income earned worldwide, including profits from selling or trading these assets, even if you’ve already paid taxes on them in India.
What are the IRS rules for mutual funds and stocks held in India?
The IRS has specific rules for mutual funds and stocks. Mutual funds held outside the US are treated as passive foreign investment companies (PFICs) and require additional reporting through Form 8621.
This form must be filed for each mutual fund owned, regardless of whether you have sold the investment or not. Missing this filing can result in penalties starting at US$10,000 per form.
Mutual funds in India, such as those managed through HDFC or ICICI accounts, fall under the PFIC rules. The IRS considers these funds foreign investments and applies heavier reporting and tax obligations compared to US-based funds.
On the other hand, individual stocks are simpler to handle—you only report capital gains or losses when you sell them, just like in the US. However, mutual funds require annual reporting even if they haven’t been sold.
Why do US taxes on mutual funds differ from those on stocks?
US tax laws discourage investing in foreign mutual funds due to their classification as PFICs. Even US-based index funds purchased through an Indian brokerage account are considered foreign by the IRS and taxed accordingly.
The tax code applies higher rates and additional compliance requirements to these investments.
Many expats choose to avoid foreign mutual funds altogether and instead invest through US-based brokerage accounts. Firms like Charles Schwab or Interactive Brokers allow US citizens living abroad to invest in US-based funds as they simplify tax reporting and reduce compliance costs.
Why are individual stocks a simpler choice for expats?
Investing directly in individual stocks can be a simpler alternative for US expats. Unlike mutual funds, individual stocks do not fall under PFIC rules. This means fewer reporting requirements and less risk of penalties.
When you sell individual stocks, you report the gain or loss on your US tax return. If you hold the stock for more than a year, the profits qualify for the lower long-term capital gains tax rate.
This straightforward approach allows you to stay invested in the market without the additional paperwork and heavy taxes associated with foreign mutual funds.
Many expats choose to avoid foreign mutual funds altogether and instead invest through US-based brokerage accounts. Firms like Charles Schwab or Interactive Brokers allow US citizens living abroad to invest in US-based funds as they simplify tax reporting and reduce compliance costs.
How is cryptocurrency treated for taxes in India and the US?
Cryptocurrency is treated differently in India and the US, making compliance more complex. In India, crypto gains are taxed at a flat rate, often as high as 34.5%, regardless of whether the gain is short-term or long-term.
For US taxes, the IRS considers cryptocurrency as property. If you hold crypto for over a year before selling, it qualifies for the lower long-term capital gains rate.
If you’ve already paid taxes on crypto gains in India, you can use the Foreign Tax Credit (FTC) to reduce your US tax liability. This ensures you are not taxed twice on the same income.
What steps can US expats take to simplify investing?
To avoid unnecessary complications and taxes, US expats can follow these steps:
- Avoid foreign mutual funds: These funds have high compliance requirements and are subject to higher taxes. Stick to US-based funds purchased through a US brokerage.
- Invest in individual stocks: Stocks are simpler to report and not subject to PFIC rules, making them a better option for expats.
- Open a US brokerage account: Use firms like Charles Schwab or Interactive Brokers to invest in US-based assets, reducing compliance burdens and simplifying tax filings.
- Work with a tax professional: A tax advisor with experience in US and Indian tax laws can help you manage your investments while staying compliant.
Are foreign mutual funds worth the hassle for US expats?
Foreign mutual funds can be attractive due to their returns, but the US tax system makes them costly for expats. The compliance requirements and potential penalties often outweigh the benefits.
By investing in US-based funds through a US brokerage, you can avoid these challenges and focus on growing your portfolio.
If you still wish to invest in mutual funds, ensure they are purchased through a US brokerage. This prevents the classification as a PFIC, which triggers higher taxes and even more complex reporting.
How can a professional help improve your investment strategy?
Tax advisors with expertise in international tax laws can help:
- Ensure all necessary forms are filed to avoid penalties.
- Identify opportunities to claim Foreign Tax Credits and other deductions.
- Simplify your investment portfolio to reduce compliance burdens.
- Provide strategies to minimize taxes while staying within IRS guidelines.
The IRS has strict rules for reporting foreign income and investments. Missing even one filing can lead to steep fines. Professional guidance ensures you stay compliant while maximizing your investment returns.
If you still wish to invest in mutual funds, ensure they are purchased through a US brokerage. This prevents the classification as a PFIC, which triggers higher taxes and even more complex reporting.
Why partner with a specialist Expat accountant?
Living outside of the US can make your tax filing requirements complicated. To ensure you pay the minimum amount of taxes, it’s critical to work with an accountant who understands every aspect and avenue for reducing your tax liability. We have a dedicated team of tax accountants who work exclusively with US expats earning and investing in Germany. Partnering with a specialist expat accountant can help you navigate complex tax regulations and optimize your tax situation.
